Best Murder/Mystery Games for 5 Players

Mystery of the Abbey with The Pilgrims' Chronicles

2007

6.96

3-6 players 60-90 min 2.24/5

Mysterium

2015

7.19

2-7 players 42 min 1.89/5

Mansions of Madness

2011

7.25

2-5 players 120 min 3.24/5

Tajemnicze Domostwo

2013

7.08

2-7 players 30-60 min 1.83/5

A Study in Emerald

2013

7.21

2-5 players 90 min 3.46/5

Watson & Holmes

2015

7.24

2-7 players 45-75 min 2.16/5

Mystery of the Abbey

1995

6.54

3-6 players 120 min 2.20/5

A Study in Emerald (second edition)

2015

6.87

2-5 players 60 min 2.94/5

Mystery Express

2010

6.55

3-5 players 60-90 min 2.66/5

Unusual Suspects

2015

6.39

3-18 players 10-30 min 1.09/5

Mord im Arosa

2010

6.53

2-6 players 30 min 1.44/5

Kill Doctor Lucky

1996

6.16

3-8 players 45 min 1.64/5

Clue Master Detective

1988

6.67

3-10 players 60 min 1.84/5

Black Stories

2004

5.99

2-15 players 20 min 1.26/5

In a Grove

2011

6.34

3-4 players 20 min 1.44/5

Ultimate Werewolf: Inquisition

2013

6.51

3-12 players 30-60 min 1.68/5

Clue: Harry Potter Edition

2008

6.21

3-5 players 30 min 1.58/5

Black Stories 2

2005

6.15

2-15 players 20 min 1.21/5

Clue: Discover the Secrets

2008

6.11

3-6 players 60 min 1.80/5

Sherlock Holmes: The Card Game

1991

6.13

3-8 players 60 min 1.49/5

Save Doctor Lucky

2000

5.85

3-7 players 30 min 1.49/5

Black Stories 3

2006

6.04

2-15 players 45 min 1.24/5

Black Stories Funny Death Edition

2011

5.99

2-15 players 20 min 1.00/5

Hoax (second edition)

2016

5.89

3-6 players 10-20 min 1.76/5

Clue: The Card Game

2002

5.82

3-5 players 45 min 1.55/5

Clue VCR Mystery Game

1985

5.98

2-10 players 60 min 1.81/5

Cluedo Super Sleuth

1995

6.11

2-6 players 30 min 2.11/5

Super Cluedo Challenge

1986

5.99

2-9 players 120 min 2.18/5

CLUE: Firefly Edition

2014

6.39

3-6 players 90 min 2.25/5

CLUE: The Big Bang Theory

2013

5.87

2-6 players 45 min 1.78/5

Black Stories Real Crime Edition

2009

5.66

2-15 players 20 min 1.27/5

The Amberden Affair

2013

5.72

3-6 players 45 min 1.75/5

Black Stories Mystery Edition

2007

5.47

2-15 players 20 min 1.12/5

Black Stories: Das Spiel

2008

4.73

3-13 players 20-222 min 1.40/5

The Da Vinci Code Board Game: The Quest for the Truth

2006

5.16

2-6 players 120 min 1.95/5